Currently set to Index
Currently set to Follow

Crappie Electronics? Not Hardly! The Best Fish Finders for Crappie Fishing

Written by: John Baltes
Last Updated:
We participate in various affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links.

If you’re in the market for a new crappie fish finder, we’re here to help. Below, you’ll find a comprehensive guide to help you buy the best fish finder for crappie.

Quick glance at the top fish finders for crappie fishing:


Summary

And while Garmin isn’t disclosing much in the way of technical specifications, you can be pretty sure that those numbers match or exceed the published info on the ULTRA 126SV.

So let’s get into the details.

The ULTRA 2 comes in two screen sizes: a 10-inch and a 12-inch diagonal. For a flagship purchase, we’d opt for the larger screen for better legibility.

Garmin’s screen tech is outstanding, and the color palette is vibrant. It’s also easy to read in full sunlight, and legible at relatively extreme angles.

Like the ECHOMAP ULTRA 126SV, you can count on legibility that allows more than one angler to share this 12-inch screen without compromising the ability to notice details at a glance.

As you’d expect from Garmin’s extensive experience designing easy-to-navigate UIs, they’ve really nailed this one, and if there’s any one dominant selling point for Garmin, it’s that their fish finders are the easiest to use on the water, hands down.

In the real world, this means that after a few minutes familiarizing yourself with the touchscreen - another reason to go big - you won’t need to study the manual or bring it with you fishing. The UI is intuitive, simple, and no more challenging than your smart phone.

The ULTRA 2 comes equipped with the GT56UHD-TM transducer, also available for the ULTRA 126SV. It provides outstanding performance in water less than 60 feet deep, making it an ideal choice for freshwater fishing.

It also supports the Livescope system, Garmin’s answer to Lowrance’s LIVE and Humminbird’s Live Target. Able to capture live video with amazing detail, this is a game-changing tool.

The GT56 is equipped with a variety of CHIRP sonar options, including ClearVu down imaging and SideVu side imaging.

On the big 12-inch screen, down- and side-scanning CHIRP sonar become your best friends on the water, and in most places you’ll fish bass, crappie, walleye, or perch, you’ll be able to side scan for fish as you move, covering lots of water really quickly before moving in for the kill with down-imaging or the optional Livescope.

Garmin’s industry-leading mapping software, pre-loaded maps, and GPS tech will revolutionize the way you fish.

And robust networking options allow you to control Garmin Force trolling motors directly from your screen. 

A direct rival for the best Humminbird and Lowrance have to offer, the Garmin ECHOMAP ULTRA 2 is a tournament-winning piece of fishing tech.

Specifications

Display Size: 12”
Resolution: 1280 x 800
Frequencies: single channel CHIRP, 70/83/200 kHz, L, M, H CHIRP; ClearVu 260/455/800/1000/1200 kHz; SideVu 260/455/800/1000/1200 kHz
Maximum Depth: ?
Transducer Angles: ?
Target Separation: ?
GPS: Yes
Maps: Yes

Pros & Cons

PROS:

  • Awesome screen
  • Very easy to use; excellent UI
  • Excellent depth and range
  • ClearVü and SideVü
  • CHIRP and standard sonar options that cover a very wide range of frequencies
  • Powerful networking options
  • Quickdraw Contours mapping
  • Built -in maps and GPS

CONS:

  • Adding the Livescope system raises the price quite a bit

The Lowrance HDS Live 12 is clearly designed for anglers who make a living on the water, whether that’s tournament fishermen or chapter captains. A head-to-head competitor with the Solix 12, this Lowrance features remarkable bleeding-edge tech.

In short, feature for feature, it meets or exceeds the performance of the Solix 12, with the exception of overall image quality. There, Humminbird reigns supreme.

The HDS Live 12 sports a 12-inch diagonal screen with awesome resolution. Crisp and clear even in bright sun, it’s touch-capable and augmented by the usual keypad, enabling accessibility no matter the conditions.

Powered by the amazing Simrad Active Imaging 3-in-1 Transom Mount Transducer, expect CHIRP, traditional sonar, and side-imaging. Offering a bit more range in side-scanning than the Solix, it probably surrenders the ultra-high frequencies to Humminbird, perhaps explaining why its image quality can’t quite compete.

That’s not saying the HDS Live doesn’t provide good images - they’re amazing!

Some specifications are not available from either Lowrance or Simrad Yachting (the same company since 2006), such as transducer beam angle or target separation. Normally, that would give us pause: if you’re proud of a product’s performance, you’re going to offer that info! But real-world performance has demonstrated the HDS Live 12’s abilities beyond doubt, and we wouldn’t hesitate to use this fish finder.

In CHIRP mode, water penetration is awesome, punching down to 1,000 feet. DownScan is a very-high-frequency mode, roughly analogous to Humminbird’s MEGA system, providing incredible crisp, clear images at the cost of depth.

But where Lowrance kills its competition is the integration of GPS and mapping tech. Here, their experience in marine navigation is more than evident. The excellent C-Map US Inland mapping and US/Canada Navionics+ card make GPS plotting and charting a breeze. And like Humminbird, Lowrance offers a real-time mapping feature, Genesis Live. Capable of creating ½-foot contour maps, it’s tournament-winning and customer-pleasing tech at its best.

And of course, the HDS Live series offers outstanding connectivity options, including SmartSteer control for the Xi5 trolling motor and Outboard Pilot, an aftermarket course-plotting system for single and dual outboards.

Does the Lowrance edge out the Humminbird, recapturing the top spot in our reviews?

We think it does, and if you can afford it, it’s simply the best fishfinder on the market this year.

Display Size: 12”
Resolution: 1280 X 800
Frequencies: CHIRP (83/200kHz) as well as traditional 455/800kHz
Side Scanning: Yes, 150’
Maximum Depth: CHIRP 1,000’; DownScan 300’
Transducer Angle: ?
Target Separation: ?
GPS: Yes
Maps: Yes

PROS:

  • Awesome screen and image quality
  • Good depth and range
  • CHIRP and standard sonar options
  • Powerful GPS and maps
  • Lake mapping feature
  • Pairs with your mobile
  • Powerful connectivity options

CONS:

  • Expensive!

Summary

Their CHIRP does just that. Take the already capable Pro+, further improve the transducer, add awesome CHIRP sonar tech, give it a better battery, and decrease the target separation to less than a half-inch, and you get an unbeatable casting fishfinder.

Let’s get right down to it.

The New Deeper CHIRP 2 features a three-band CHIRP sonar, offering your choice of lower frequencies to punch through the water column down to 330 feet, mid-range frequencies to provide depth and better detail, and high frequencies to maximize its fish-finding potential.

As you’d expect, the higher the frequencies the narrower the cone angle and the better the detail.

In Narrow CHIRP, for instance, you’ll be running the gamut of frequencies around the 675 kHz range, using a transducer beam angle of just 7° that provides target separation of less than ½ inch.

That’s pretty impressive for any fish finder, let alone a castable model that won’t set your budget back a month!

Deeper has significantly upgraded the battery in the CHIRP 2, more than doubling its usable life on the water while keeping recharging times fast. You can be back on the water after just an hour charging with 80% of your battery.

That’s impressive.

Keep in mind that in the real world, the 15 hour battery life is probably a bit exaggerated. Expect less than that, but the recharge times are accurate.

It’s also worth noting that like all portable fish finders, the stated range is optimistic.

But these are weaknesses no portable fish finder can avoid, and the Deeper CHIRP 2 isn’t just an improvement on the older model; it leaves its competition in the dust.

It’s compatible with Apple’s iOS 14.0 and later, as well as Android’s 8.0 Oreo and later (on phones equipped with Bluetooth and WiFi).

And if you’re willing to pay a bit more, Deeper offers access to community-based 2D depth maps and 3D bathymetric maps, giving you all the tools you need to fish smarter.

At this price point, the Deeper CHIRP 2 is ridiculously good.

Specifications

Maximum depth: 330 feet
Maximum range: 330 feet
Transducer beam angle: 7° in Narrow Chirp, 20° in Medium Chirp, and 47°in Wide Chirp
Frequency: Narrow CHIRP 675 kHz, Medium CHIRP 240 kHz, Wide CHIRP 100 kHz
Target separation: 0.4 in Narrow Chirp, 0.94 in Medium Chirp, 0.94 in Wide Chirp
Compatibility: iOS 14.0 and later and Android 8.0 Oreo and later (with Bluetooth and WiFi)
Battery life: up to 15 hours
Charging time: Fast charge, 80% in 60 min., 100% in 110 min.

Pros & Cons

PROS:

  • Easy to use
  • Uncomplicated interface makes the CHIRP easy to read and understand
  • Very inexpensive for the tech you get
  • Excellent battery life and recharging rate
  • Awesome fishing tech for ice and small boats
  • Amazing target separation
  • CHIRP sonar is the best in the business
  • Premium maps available

CONS:

  • ???

Summary

The heart of this unit is the excellent XNT 9 DI T transducer, offering dual-frequency sonar at 200 and 455 kHz. This provides excellent overall depth and detail, and when paired with the 4.3-inch screen, it features admirably sharp images. That DI in the name indicates “down imaging,” a system that provides much more precise images than conventional sonar systems.

As you can see below, this is much more than a marketing gimmick.

Piranhamax screen

While not rivaling the tech in the Helix 10, blobs become stumps on the Piranhamax screen.

That’s a feature competitors can’t match, and if you’re in the market for an inexpensive fish finder, this is an excellent choice, in no small part due to this tech.

With a range of transducer angles to choose from, you can select wider beams for shallower water or narrower beams when you’re out deep. And with as much as 600 feet of bottom-finding sonar, most anglers will be well served. When paired to electronics that provide 2.5 inches of target specification, whether you’re after crappie or bass, pike or perch, you’ll be able to see the fish you’re looking for.

So what’s missing?

CHIRP, side-scanning sonar, a big screen, GPS, and maps. The otherwise capable PIRANHAMAX can’t help you with waypointing, course charting, or GPS marking.

That said, it offers great performance for anglers who are budget-conscious or fishing with a paddle rather than an outboard.

Specifications

Display Size: 4.3”
Resolution: 272 X 480
Frequencies: 200/455/455 kHz
Side Scanning: No
Down Imaging: Yes, 320’
Maximum Depth: 320 ft (20) 455 kHz, 600 ft (20) 200 kHz
Transducer Angle: 28°, 16°, and 74° @ -10dB
Target Separation: 2.5”
GPS: No
Maps: No

Pros & Cons

PROS:

  • Awesome price!
  • Acceptable screen size
  • Good depth and range
  • Dual sonar
  • Powerful down imaging that’s no gimmick

CONS:

  • No CHIRP
  • No side-scanning
  • No GPS
  • No maps

Summary

The Striker 4 offers a 3.5-inch screen that gives up some room to its Humminbird rival. And certainly, Humminbird’s down imaging provides a clearer image--no contest. So what does the Striker do to earn a place on our list?

CHIRP.

The heart of the Striker 4 is an excellent CHIRP-capable transducer, broadcasting on frequencies ranging between 50 and 200 kHz. That provides great depth and range, as well as excellent fish identification. So while image quality lags, fish finding doesn’t--and that’s what this tech is all about.

Garmin has chosen not to disclose which transducer the Striker 4 is paired with, so we can’t tell you specifics like beam angles and target separation. But what we can say is that this unit works like a charm, is easy to navigate, and provides excellent budget-priced GPS features like waypointing and marking. These features are nothing to scoff at, and if you’re willing to give up image quality to the Humminbird, this Garmin might be the best budget fish finder for you.

Specifications

Display Size: 3.5”
Resolution: 320 X 480
Frequencies: CHIRP 50/77/200 kHz
Side Scanning: No
Maximum Depth: 1,600’ freshwater; 750’ saltwater
Transducer Angle: ?
Target Separation: ?
GPS: Yes
Maps: No

Pros & Cons

PROS:

  • Awesome price!
  • Acceptable screen size
  • Good depth and range
  • CHIRP
  • GPS

CONS:

  • No side-scanning
  • No maps
  • Image quality is lower and suffers in comparison to the similar Humminbird

What We Consider When Selecting a Fish Finder for Crappie Fishing

Obviously, we prefer CHIRP sonar systems. But what else matters?

Target Separation

Target separation is simply a measure of how precise the fish finder’s sonar is at distinguishing individual fish from one another. Smaller numbers mean better performance.

Transducer Beam Angle

Often a selling point, this is not nearly as important as marketing leads you to believe.

All other things being equal:

Wider angles let you see a greater area below your transducer.

But, and this is a big but, the “specified cone” isn’t the actual area the fish finder reads. Instead, it’s shaped more like this:

tranducer beam angle

Moreover, for a specified beam width, the structure of the bottom can greatly affect performance. And the greater that width, the more likely this problem is.

transducer beam width

As a general rule, the shallower the water you fish, the wider the transducer beam angle you want. Too much will create problems, and if you fish in deeper water, you want a tighter, more focused beam angle.

Side Imaging Sonar

This is exactly what it sounds like. Some advanced fish finders offer specialized transducers that transmit and receive off the starboard and port sides of your boat. The result is a 2-D image of the water column to either side.

Some brands sport a range of as much as 800 feet in either direction!

Obviously, this can be incredibly useful for locating fish, and it’s an increasingly popular option. Be aware, however, that the depth of these side-facing transducers is limited. Side imaging sonar won’t be penetrating the water column very far, though it’s an awesome compliment to a traditional transducer.

Down Imaging

Down imaging can provide hyper-realistic images of cover and structure, turning blobs into trees and smudges into brush piles.

For crappie anglers, the ability to differentiate a rock or hump from a brush pile can be game-changing, and down imaging is definitely a feature we look for.

Maximum Depth

You want a fish finder with good maximum depth, and you want to match this rating to your actual use. Especially if you fish deeper water, like the Great Lakes, or if you’re a saltwater angler, this is something to consider carefully.

Display Size and Resolution

Larger displays are easier to read and use, but of course, they cost more, too.

And bigger isn’t always better.

Resolution is a measure of how much detail a fish finder’s screen can provide, and a small screen with great resolution can be easier to read than a large screen with only average resolution.

GPS and Maps

We think these are now nearly essential considerations in a good fish finder.

From careful waypointing to honey hole marking, GPS and maps add so much functionality that they’re almost a no-brainer.

Final Thoughts

Whether you chase crappie from a bass boat, a kayak, or the confines of the shore, there’s an excellent fish finder built for your needs--and we hope this article has helped you narrow down your choice.

If it has, we’d love to hear from you, so please leave a comment below.

About the Author

John Baltes
Chief Editor & Contributor
If it has fins, John has probably tried to catch it from a kayak. His favorite species include large- and smallmouth bass, crappie, specks, and reds. John is also a dedicated ultralight angler, and there's nothing he loves more than catching big bass on very light tackle.

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles
Tackle Reviews